Celebrating the Past, Anticipating the Future at Garden City Church
ST. PAUL, November 8, 2026
Garden City’s Logo
Garden City Church celebrated 40 years of gospel ministry on Sunday evening, bringing together members old and new to re-member and rejoice over God’s work in this local assembly.
Planted by Pastor Larry Willman in November 1986, Payne Evangelical Free Church, located in a storefront on Payne Avenue, held its first service with about a dozen in attendance. After decades of faithful ministry in the City of St. Paul, Willman retired, and the church called Rev. Jason Andersen as Senior Pastor in February 2025. Under his leadership, the church aims, according to its website, “to continue the legacy of being a simple, faithful church with roots planted deeply on the East Side of St. Paul.”
Clarence Dowell leads a congregational prayer.
Willman and his wife, Deanne, were in Mexico and unable to attend the gathering, but they shared some memories and encouraging remarks via video. Willman started the church at a time when many city churches were fleeing urban environments and leaving gaps. He commented, “We were trying to reverse that trend, if possible.” The work wasn’t easy. But they persisted. He reflected on the difficult years, observing that starting a church is like life: “You try certain things and if it doesn’t work, well then, you keep trying. Trust God.”
The Andersen Family
Jason and his wife, Ami, have demonstrated the same trust in their ministry efforts. Urban ministry can be difficult, but the Andersens believe that God is at work in the City to bring new life in Christ Jesus. That trust is reflected in the church’s new name. On April 12, 2026, the congregation voted to change the name to Garden City. The church’s website explains that the name “reflects the biblical idea that we are citizens of the heavenly ‘Garden City’ of God that he is building in his church.”
The celebration service included congregational singing led by Ami Andersen, along with Julie and Andrew Thoreen (First Evangelical Free Church of Maplewood), the Willmans’ video, and a sermon by Dan Moose, who walked alongside Willman through many years of ministry and participated in the leadership transition to Andersen. Clarence Dowell, the newest member at Garden City, offered a prayer, and Rev. Bryan Lair, Senior Pastor of Trinity City Church, led a benediction and commissioning of the Andersen family. After the service ended, attendees wrote out prayers for Garden City, as well as memories of God’s work through this assembly. And, of course, there were plenty of refreshments enjoyed by those in attendance.
The music team: Ami Anderson, Julie & Andrew Thoreen
Trinity City has a special relationship with Garden City that extends beyond a shared vision for gospel ministry in St. Paul. Jason served as a pastoral resident at Trinity City from 2023 to 2025. During that time, Ami served as a musician-in-residence. The Andersen family is now one of Trinity’s Gospel Partners: individuals or ministries that contribute to Trinity’s vision “to make the gospel walkable by increasing Christian presence in every neighborhood of our city, and through the Church in our city, contribute to the increased Christian presence globally.”
Dan Moose delivered a sermon.
One way that Trinity will support and encourage Garden City this year is through the Children’s Bible and Book Drive during the Advent season, organized by Dcn. Allison Pitts, who oversees Trinity’s Kids Ministry. The aim of this drive is to build a library for the children and youth at Garden City. Pitts said, “What’s exciting about this drive specifically is that kids get to participate in giving resources to other kids that will help them learn about God. They are gifting books that can help other kids grow in the faith.”
Pitts reflected that the drive is an especially fitting effort to serve a Gospel Partner because it helps the kids at Trinity learn to serve and care for the global Church. Trinity folks can participate in this book drive by donating new or gently used books from the Amazon Wish list or through a financial gift.
Commissioning prayer led by Bryan Lair
Garden City Church anticipates God’s continued work in its assembly, prayerfully seeking his aid as it pursues its vision to “worship our triune God, equip the church with the gospel, and care for the broken.” To stay informed about the ministry at Garden City Church, you can subscribe to Andersen’s monthly-ish newsletter HERE.

